So here we are...one week from taking Isabelle's pacifiers away. I have to admit, it went better than I thought it would...but at the same time it's been worse than I thought too. Let me explain. After we cut the pacifier last Saturday, we discovered the worst part of it all was putting her to sleep and after she she woke up. Tantrums ensued...tears were shed on both Isabelle's and my account...and wanting to give up and give in to her was definitely considered. I think the longest tantrum she threw was about an hour and a half. However by Thursday, the tantrums were only five minutes and for the most part, we don't have all out tantrums anymore when it is bed time and time to get up. So, it that respect, here we are a week later totally weaned and it wasn't tooooo bad...considering. Now for the other side of things. While Isabelle could definitely throw a tantrum before, we'd never seen anything like we have in the past week. Ultimately I believe this is because when she threw tantrums before, we would give her the pacifier and she would calm down. Now, she doesn't have that, so she is having to learn how to sooth herself without the pacifier. I definitely did NOT see this coming...and this is definitely the hardest part. Now instead of a hitting problem, we have a hitting and a kicking and a tantrum throwing problem. Instead of five minute tantrums, we have all out 45 minute tantrums that the only way she can pull herself out of it is by either going to sleep or me somehow distracting her with a song or going outside. One reason this is also really hard is for the same reason getting rid of the pacifier was hard. I'm just as addicted to putting it in her mouth as she is...and I just want to give into her when she throws a tantrum to make it stop. We are definitely all a work in progress, because Curt has his issues too like wanting to yell, but that doesn't work either... Ugh, we are definitely all struggling trying to figure out the best way to handle this. Overall, I can honestly say my child no longer gets a pacifier and that she is completely weaned. We just have a whole host of other problems to deal with now...
Need advice? I put together my own FAQs. :)
Things I wish I'd known/done before taking the pacifier away:
- I wish I'd taken the pacifier away before the crib. Then she could've cried it out in her crib instead of in the bed next to me kicking my belly. Can I say ouch enough times? Trust me. It hurts and tests EVERY bit of patience I have!
- Originally without the pacifier she attached herself to her favorite blanket. A day or two in I thought this was a good thing. Then after a 45 minute temper tantrum about her "manket," of which she had the whole time, I changed my mind. I'm pretty sure she wanted to use the blanket to sooth herself, however the blanket obviously didn't sooth her in the way the pacifier did, so she got really really frustrated with it. Now we are to the point that the blanket does more harm than good.
- For us, one of the automatic pacifier times was in the car. We had gotten to the point that during the day, the car rides were the most addicted to the pacifier times. To wean her off these times, we sing to her fun songs. I wish I had acquired a CD of some sort with fun kid songs on it before going cold turkey.
- I'm not totally convinced going cold turkey is the way to go. Of course there are benefits of doing it...however, I would think emotionally for both Isabelle and me it would have been better to go with our first idea and take it away during the day...then the car seat...then naps...then bedtime and then be done. Of course this would take a lot longer and it would be much easier to cheat. However, I think this has been a really rough week for Isabelle when it comes to learning and being pushed pretty far really fast.
- I think 18 months is a rough age to do this at. I know it would be rough at any age, but I wish I'd done it during the 9 to 12 month window. I think if I had done it then we would have had to wean ourselves more than her. Except that's when her sleeping was having the biggest issues and when I stopped breast feeding too, so I don't now how that would have worked either. Doing it older sucks too, but I think that mentally they can process why more. I got advice to do the "You don't need a pacifier, you're a big girl..." approach, however Isabelle has no comprehension of what that means. I was scared that she wouldn't understand the broken pacifiers, but she learned what that meant pretty fast. If I use the pacifier again for our other children, I would probably wean them at a year and definitely no later than 14 or 15 months.
Would I use the pacifier again?
- I honestly don't know. Isabelle had a really really rough beginning. Of course during the rough beginning she didn't really take the pacifier either... I pretty much forced it on her and she didn't really like it until about four months. However, I would totally do it again for Isabelle. She had issues with her suck to...she thrusted her tongue out when she sucked...which KILLED me as a nursing mother. Once she finally figured out the pacifier and learned to suck different so she could keep it in, everything nursing-wise took care of itself. If it hadn't worked out this way, I don't know what I would have done. I was so determined to nurse and not give up, but the pain was intolerable at times. So, for that reason alone I'm grateful for the pacifier.
- Another reason I'm pro-pacifier is it kept Isabelle's hands out of her mouth. Now that she doesn't have it, the hands are in her mouth. She doesn't suck on them, but she chews and actually bites them. Plus it is really gross to me. Curt and I were both thumb suckers and we want to avoid this with our kids as much as we possibly can.
- I definitely see the value to not having the pacifier, however for us, the pacifier had more pros than cons and still does. However for the next babies in our lives, we'll take it on an individual by individual approach. So, we'll see.